News and Events

Feb 13, 2019

UPDATE: Arrest of Advisory Board Member Maria Ressa

On December 7, 2018, the D4D Coalition Advisory Board issued a statement of solidarity condemning the indictment of fellow Advisory Board member and Rappler CEO Maria Ressa. In light of Maria Ressa’s arrest on February 13, 2019, on charges of cyber libel, the Coalition reaffirms the solidarity expressed in that statement, and reiterates its condemnation of efforts by Philippine government to silence Rappler. The charges stem from a seven-year-old story that predates the enactment of the 2012 Cybercrime Prevention Act. The arrest follows a string of charges leveled against Ressa by the Philippine government, which are part of a broader attempt to silence independent and critical voices in the country. For her work as a guardian in the war against truth, Ressa was named one of Time Magazine’s 2018 Persons of the Year and was the 2018 recipient of the Committee to Protect Journalism’s Gwen Ifill Press Freedom Award. Today the D4D Coalition echoes Ressa’s remarks upon accepting the award, “The time to fight for journalism . . . is now.”

Dec 18, 2018

Chinese Influence Detected during Taiwanese Elections

A bipartisan group of U.S. Senators led by Catherine Cortez Masto (D-Nev.) and Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) have written a letter to U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo asking for an investigation into “CCP attempts to erode democratic processes and norms around the world threaten U.S. partnerships and prosperity,” particularly in regards to Taiwan. They suggest that organized social media campaigns targeted the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), its candidates and President Tsai Ing-wen during local elections in November. Observers in Taiwan and elsewhere have said that the Chinese government supported these opposition campaigns with different forms of computational propaganda, and the Senators’ letter suggested they find the allegations credible and want them investigated.

Dec 17, 2018

US Senate Releases Two Reports on Russian Interference in 2016 Elections

The US Senate Intelligence Committee released two externally produced reports that provide further data on the 2016 national elections, including one partly authored by D4D Advisory Board member Philip Howard, Director of the Oxford Internet Institute in collaboration with Graphika, a data analytics firm, and a second by New Knowledge, another company studying social media and disinformation. The reports find much broader usage of social media accounts linked across platforms, particularly targeting conservative voters and African Americans. Platforms such as Instagram and YouTube have received less attention in the media, but were also found to have been used by groups such as the Russian Internet Research Agency, while the researchers also suggested that social media platforms would need to share more data to fully understand the full scope of the campaigns. The Senate Intelligence Committee plans to release its own report on these issues in the near future.

Dec 17, 2018

International IDEA Collaborates with Electoral Tribunal to Support Digital Media Unit

D4D network partner International IDEA has entered into a collaboration with the Electoral Tribunal of Panama in order to provide support to the newly created Digital Media Unit. The unit’s mandate is twofold. On one side, it is in charge of the online communication of the Tribunal in terms of Electoral information, providing a key line of information to the population through Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and Whatsapp with the key electoral information. On the other, the Digital Media Unit is spearheading the fight against disinformation, with a 24/7 monitoring of social media war room, supporting the Tribunal to detect electoral offenses, campaigns to raise awareness around the dangers of spreading disinformation and engagement with diverse stakeholders to protect the electoral integrity. The Unit has also been in charge of launching the country’s first Digital Ethics Pact, encouraging the population to make responsible use of social media during the electoral campaign. International IDEA support will continue until the elections in May 2019 and beyond, aiming to position the Unit as the leader in the fight against disinformation in Panama.

Dec 16, 2018

Maria Ressa Faces Jail Time, Named ‘Guardian’ of Democratic Norms

The CEO of Rappler, a Philippine “Social News Network,” and D4D Advisory Board Member Maria Ressa has been charged by the Philippine government with tax evasion and failure to file tax returns; she could face up to ten years in prison. At the same time, she has been named one of Time Magazine’s 2018 Persons of the Year, part of what they call “the Guardians,” a group of journalists fighting for democratic values around the world. Ressa has been outspoken in her criticism of Philippines President Rodrigo Duterte’s violent “war on drugs,” and other policies, while through research and analysis Rappler’s team have illuminated the influence campaigns and computational propaganda tactics his government and followers have pursued online.

Dec 15, 2018

IFES Pilots Holistic Exposure and Adaptation Testing in Ukraine

D4D coalition member IFES is currently piloting its Holistic Exposure and Adaptation Testing (HEAT) process in Ukraine. The HEAT process is a method for identifying and testing the potential exploitation of vulnerabilities in the use of election data management technology. HEAT tests the technology itself, as well as the legal and operational frameworks in which the technology is being deployed. As part of the pilot, IFES conducted a cybersecurity assessment in summer 2018 and a cybersecurity tabletop simulation with the Ukrainian Central Election Commission in November 2018.

Dec 7, 2018

D4D Coalition Advisory Board Stands in Solidarity with Fellow Member Maria Ressa and Rappler

The Design 4 Democracy Coalition Advisory Board stands in solidarity with our fellow member Maria Ressa and with Rappler, the leading independent online news outlet in the Philippines. Ressa and Rappler Holdings were formally indicted on November 29, 2018, on charges of tax evasion—the latest action by the Philippine government in attempting to thwart the work of Rappler’s journalists—and Ressa turned herself into authorities and posted bail this week.

Dec 5, 2018

EU Announces Action Plan to Protect Upcoming Election

The European Union announced a plan to counter disinformation ahead of the 2019 European elections. The plan includes increased resources for outside researchers and fact-checkers, strict enforcement of the platformed-signed Code of Practice, and the introduction of the Rapid Alert System. In collaboration with the European Parliament and individual member states, the EU will work to have the Rapid Alert System operational by March 2019.

Nov 30, 2018

In Afghanistan, Disinformation Increases Ethnic Tensions

Following protests against the arrest of Afghan militia commander Alipoor, tensions were heightened by disinformation spread through social media. Government security forces posted that no civilians were harmed, while protesters circulated photos of a dead schoolgirl and others. National Directorate of Security Chief Massoum Stanekzai reported that commander Alipoor was arrested by the U.S. Military. However, a spokesperson for U.S. forces tweeted that they had no involvement. The government narrative was bolstered by photos of wounded security officers which were exposed to have been taken years prior.

Nov 27, 2018

At the Inaugural Grand Committee on Disinformation Meeting in London

At the Inaugural Grand Committee on Disinformation, an empty chair was left for Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg, who turned down invitations to testify before the international committee of lawmakers. In his place, Facebook Vice President Richard Allan faced hard-hitting questions about email communication found within documents seized by the UK parliament and Facebook’s role in global democracy challenges. At the close of the hearing, members of parliament from around the world signed a declaration of ‘Principles of the Law Governing the Internet.’ Simultaneously, MP Damian Collins, Chair of the UK parliament’s Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee, pressured, under threat of imprisonment, the founder of the social media application developer Six4Three to hand over internal Facebook documents and emails, which have now been released by the committee and demonstrate its policy development, strategy and internal deliberations over data sharing with third-party developers, among other issues.

Nov 23, 2018

New Google Political Ad Policies Fall Short of the Mark

In an attempt to increase transparency of political ads ahead of the 2019 EU Parliamentary Elections, Google has announced new policies that will require ad posters name the organization that provides their funding. The parameters for a ‘political ad,’ however, are too narrow to capture much of the politically motivated content that is expected throughout the election period, sparking worry that these new policies will prove ineffective.

Nov 20, 2018

Human Rights Impact Assessment, Facebook in Myanmar

An independent BSR report, commissioned by Facebook, about the impact of the platform on the human rights crisis in Myanmar found evidence that Facebook did not take enough action to prevent violence from being spread on its site. Thousands of people have died in the conflict, with hundreds of thousands more displaced internally and into neighboring Bangladesh. The report warns Facebook of future human rights abuses around the 2020 elections and calls for the company to both create a new human rights policy and enforce its current hate speech policies by working with the local authorities.

Nov 17, 2018

The Fight Against Disinformation in the U.S.: A Landscape Analysis

The Harvard University Shorenstein Center for Media Studies published The Fight Against Disinformation in the U.S.: A Landscape Analysis, which explores the key players, tactics, and support for learning and programmatic responses to viral digital culture. Societal changes impact the way that we use media, but these shifts are in all directions. When the way that people communicate changes, this is reflected in a shift in society as well. The paper discusses the impacts of the changes in media use on American culture and the ways in which some people are trying to combat the negative impact of computational propaganda, disinformation and other harmful forms of content.

Nov 17, 2018

Common-Knowledge Attacks on Democracy

In new research from Harvard’s Berkman Klein Center, Henry Farrell and Bruce Schneier argue that nations should approach disinformation as they approach other issues of state security. Different vulnerabilities are presents and potential responses are required depending on the type of government structure; autocracy or democracy. While autocracies produce contested knowledge about political actors themselves, democracies produce contested information about who holds power. This causes democracies to be more susceptible to narratives about general political organization.

Nov 15, 2018

Russian Meddling in U.S. Election Is No Surprise

A three-part New York Times documentary series explores Russian meddling in the 2016 U.S. election in the context of the wider Russian effort to divide the West. From the inception of Soviet fake news to its use today, the NYT uncovers the continuation of Russian interference in the United States and the reasons why the U.S. government and other nations are so woefully unprepared to counter this disinformation campaign.

Nov 14, 2018

Venezuelan Government Introduces Chinese Technology to Monitor Citizens

First seen in China, Venezuela has adopted an RFID smart card system that allows the government to track citizen behavior. This Fatherland Card, made by Chinese telecom giant ZTE Corp, collects information including healthcare data, voting participation, and subsidized food distribution in a central database. In a country where many citizens rely on government programs to feed their families and receive medical care, opponents are calling the government’s requirement that citizens obtain the Fatherland card to access services akin to blackmail.

Nov 14, 2018

Information Warfare: A New Theater of Battle

The British Army’s 77th Brigade, a group of skilled social media analysts, graphic designers, video producers, and content writers, are hard at work running the nation’s information warfare program. This group is not alone in its focus on the importance of public opinion in conflict; other countries including the United States and Russia know the power of deploying information warfare. The 77th Brigade counters false narratives, works to improve public sentiment in conflict zones, and influences public opinion to strengthen the position of the British Army.

Nov 14, 2018

A United Call from World Leaders for Action Against Disinformation

Following the Paris Peace Forum from November 11th to 13th, the leaders of Canada, France, Norway, Costa Rica, Tunisia, Senegal, and Lebanon authored an opinion piece in The Star. They acknowledged the growing threat of disinformation to journalism and the citizens of their countries, applauded the presentation of the International Information and Democracy Commission at the Forum, and called for further action within their own nations and around the world.

Nov 13, 2018

Governance Innovation for a Connected World

The Center for International Governance Innovation recently released a report that informs questions regarding responsibility for regulating and supervising the internet, and how society can be protected from the risks of an open internet without stifling its power of innovation. The essays included in this report detail the regulatory and political landscape of current law, impacts on censorship and civil rights, and recommendations for the role of the private sector.

Nov 12, 2018

Russia Accuses U.S. of Georgian ‘Lab of Death’ in Disinformation Campaign

In an ongoing disinformation campaign, Russia has accused the U.S. government of operating a laboratory in Georgia where scientists tested biological weapons and drugs, resulting in multiple fatalities. In response, the U.S. has accused Russia of operating a disinformation campaign to distract the world from the negative attention placed on the Kremlin by the poisonings of Russian dissidents in the United Kingdom.

Nov 12, 2018

Paris Call for Trust and Security in Cyberspace Signed by Over 50 Nations, Missing Online Superpowers

Over 50 countries signed on to the Paris Call for Trust and Security in Cyberspace, an agreement released by French President Emmanuel Macron as part of the Paris Peace Forum in November. China, Russia, Australia, North Korea, Iran, and the U.S. abstained from signing the agreement, while representing hubs for ICTs, online infrastructure and cybersecurity resources, personnel and experience. Tech companies including Facebook, Microsoft, IBM, Google, and HP also signed alongside civil society organizations and technical experts. While the agreement does not include a call for specific legislation, it does advocate for the promotion of human rights on the internet, the allocation of unique responsibilities to the private sector, and the end of hacking between nations in peacetime.

Nov 12, 2018

Citizen Engagement with Disinformation Explored in ‘Beyond Fake News’ Reports

The BBC World Service released two ‘Beyond Fake News’ reports, one focusing on India and the other on Kenya and Nigeria. While the content of viral news differed between countries, many people shared information from alternative sources because of widespread distrust of mainstream media outlets, an inflated view of their own ability to discern fact from fiction, and the desire to promote national identity over truth.

Nov 10, 2018

Russian Social Media Influence, Understanding Russian Propaganda in Eastern Europe

The RAND Corporation released a report that explores the threat of Russian-language social media activity to former Soviet states. Employing interviews with experts in security and regional politics, as well as analysis of social media data, this report digs into the Kremlin’s use of shared post-Soviet experiences to spread disinformation. The report offers recommendations including better tracking of Russian media, increasing media literacy, and improving reliable content to offer an alternative to the Kremlin agenda.

Nov 5, 2018

Data Craft, The Manipulation of Social Media Metadata

Amelia Acker’s report investigates the ways in which metadata can be manipulated to inform the disinformation efforts of bad actors, as well as strategies to stop them from misleading the public. Acker unpacks practices used by disinformation proponents to increase their impact on social media by engaging the platform’s own algorithms. Acker hopes to inform the work of technology companies and other interested parties in the fight against disinformation.

Oct 30, 2018

Data and Elections in Brazil in 2018

This research from the “Personal Data and Political Influence” Project is part of a Brazilian Country Report by Coding Rights. The 2018 Brazilian election took place amid widespread online influence campaigns, often making use of personal data to target voters. This report addresses the use of this personal data in political campaigns as well as the regulatory and ethical questions that result from its increased use.

Oct 25, 2018

D4D Coalition Launches to Help Make Tech Work for Democracy

Supported by NDI and more than a dozen other international partners, the Design 4 Democracy Coalition held its first Advisory Board meeting on October 25th, in conjunction with MisinfoCon London and Mozilla Fest (MozFest). The D4D Coalition seeks to act as a force multiplier for organizations who advocate for more democracy-friendly technology platforms and policies by providing an opportunity for collaboration and mutual support within the democracy community. The Coalition also provides direct lines of communication with major technology platforms and is improving communication between the democracy community and the tech industry.

Oct 20, 2018

NYT Roundup of Election-Related Misinformation Shows Breadth of Fake News

With election day drawing nearer, disinformation efforts to influence voters increase. The New York Times published a “Roundup” of disinformation-related coverage, its impact on the U.S. midterm elections, and its spread internationally. In response to suspicious pro-Saudi Arabian government tweets, Twitter suspended suspected bots that tweeted and re-tweeted identical talking points including “#unfollow_enemies_of_the_nation.” Twitter also released 11 million tweets believed to be from state-backed information operations originating in Russia and Iran. Facebook pages that appeared to be for Women’s Marches were found to originate in Bangladesh and sought to sell march-related merchandise.

Oct 18, 2018

IRI and NDI Presidents Discuss Tech and Democracy Collaboration in California

As part of a broader series of discussions on tech and democracy, the National Democratic Institute and International Republican Institute joined partners on October 18 to host a reception and discussion in San Francisco about the ways tech is impacting democratic processes and participation around the world. The event featured perspectives from NDI President Derek Mitchell and IRI President Dan Twining, and explored opportunities for civil society, technologists, and others to collaborate through efforts like the D4D Coalition. Participants included Bay Area stakeholders from the tech industry, academia, and the international affairs community, and co-hosts included the Pacific Council, TheBridge, and Bay Area International Link.

Oct 17, 2018

Twitter Releases Data on Russian Linked Account

In an attempt to increase transparency and enable academic investigation and research, Twitter released data about accounts and content that have been part of global disinformation campaigns since 2016. Included in the data are two accounts that had not been part of earlier releases, and are thought by Twitter to be state-backed. In total, information about 3,841 accounts connected to the IRA in Russia and 770 other accounts have been released to the public. However, researchers found even more fake Twitter accounts that appear to be linked to the Russian government that were not identified by Twitter’s search, promoting politically benign topics such as Taco Bell and Coachella.

Oct 17, 2018

Highlighting Ad Tech’s Abuse of Big Data

Data & Society published a report on “Weaponizing the Digital Influence Machine: The Political Perils of Online Ad Tech”. The paper further explains the relationship between politics, media, and ill-meaning actors. It lays out the tactics, technologies, and conditions that anti-democratic and politically-motivated actors use to weaponize digital advertising. The report finds that three main strategies are employed by actors who use the “Digital Influence Machine” to attempt to divide an opponent’s supporters, leverage behavioral science techniques to influence consumers, and mobilize those who support their views by threatening their identity, political or otherwise.

Oct 17, 2018

Brazilians Face Massive Disinfo Campaign on WhatsApp

In a New York Times op-ed, researchers and fact checkers in Brazil called on WhatsApp to make changes to its system when they found that it was being widely used to spread disinformation in the runup to the national election. A poll found that 44 percent of Brazilians use WhatsApp to read political news, and a growing amount of misinformation and disinformation has been shared widely through the app, and the writers called on the company to restrict forwards, broadcasts and limit the size of new groups in Brazil during the election period. A Facebook subsidiary, WhatsApp later banned over 100,000 accounts associated with sharing false stories, but did not take up the suggestions before the election on October 28th.

Oct 15, 2018

Myanmar’s Military Used Facebook in Shadow Campaign Against Rohingya

Hundreds of members of the Myanmar military, posing as civilians and often using tactics modeled after those used by Russia, have used Facebook to spread disinformation about the Muslim Rohingya minority. One of the largest forced human migration human history, over 700,000 people, is widely attributed to this type of anti-Rohingya propaganda and the violence it incited. Nathaniel Gleicher, Facebook’s head of cybersecurity policy, reported that the company found “clear and deliberate attempts to covertly spread propaganda that were directly linked to the Myanmar military.”

Oct 15, 2018

Google’s Controversial Chinese Search Engine Rolls On

Google’s CEO Sundar Pichai defended the company’s search engine for use in China is going well and would proceed, despite questions around such an initiative’s potential for censorship and surveillance. Mr. Pichai described the controversial decision to build the search engine as in keeping with their mission to provide information to all people. Google employees have voiced concern at this proposal, citing its commitments to the Global Network Initiative’s Principles on Freedom of Expression and Privacy.

Oct 15, 2018

A New Framework for Addressing Disinformation and Misinformation

Full Fact, a British fact-checking group, released a report entitled “Tackling misinformation in an open society. How to respond to misinformation and disinformation when the cure risks being worse than the disease.” The report explains that it is more realistic to build resilience against disinformation and misinformation in the UK than to eliminate it all together. In the paper, Full Fact sets out a framework for response to disinformation and misinformation that is proportionate and risk-based, and caution against taking action without thinking through the consequences and allowing time for further research into the harm caused by such campaigns.

Oct 8, 2018

Google+ Vulnerability Exposes User Data of Millions

A vulnerability in Google+ profiles opened user data to 438 applications between 2015 and March 2018, when the problem was discovered as part of an internal audit. This data breach resulted from a flaw in an API that was created by the tech company to allow developers to access profile information about individuals who used their apps and had given permission to share their profile data. Internal memos, investigative journalism, and a blog post shed light on Google’s decision to not go public with the information when it originally discovered the problem. Increased security measures including the termination of the Google+ service occurred in hopes of rectifying the problem. CEO Sundar Pichai has agreed to testify before Congress on the breach in the near future.

Oct 7, 2018

Civic Tech Summit in Taiwan Examines Information Integrity Issues

The Design 4 Democracy (D4D) Coalition was honored to be a part of the 2018 g0v Summit, from October 5-7, 2018. The Summit provided an opportunity to share information about the Coalition with other groups sharing similar objectives, including the Global Tech Accountability Network, a new initiative arising out of the #DearMark letter, led by organizations in Myanmar. Among the areas of collaboration discussed were the development of an open data standard on social media monitoring, together with a platform implementing the standard, for social media monitoring organizations to adapt to their own specific needs. The use of shared tools and data standards provides an opportunity for social media monitoring groups to share data with like-minded, trusted partners in other countries, providing a more complete picture of hate speech or disinformation in a regional or global context. In addition, the Summit provided an opportunity to connect with D4D partners, g0v and CoFacts, which is working with the Coalition to adapt the CoFacts fact-checking chatbot from LINE to FB Messenger and WhatsApp.

Oct 3, 2018

Facebook Launches Pilot Fact Checking Program in Kenya

Facebook is launching fact-checking tools in Kenya and plans to spread the service to the entire African continent. The fact-checking tool will demote news stories marked as fake and warn the user trying to share. The focus on Facebook’s newsfeed, however, has drawn criticism for not being the most effective use of fact-checking technology. Facebook products are highly popular in Africa, however, WhatsApp is used by far more people to communicate than Facebook, while the fact-checking service will not extend to WhatsApp.

Oct 3, 2018

Conference on Media Literacy and Disinformation in Cape Verde

D4D Coalition member NDI helped organize a conference on “Enhancing Media Literacy and Combating Disinformation” in Praia, Cape Verde in collaboration with the Cape Verdean government and The Association of Journalists of Cape Verde (AJOC). Representatives from NDI spoke on the growing threats to democratic values coming online in a new age of disinformation and suggested potential means for the media and government could use to improve information integrity in the country.

Sep 14, 2018

g0v Summit Workshop to Discuss Disinformation Monitoring

The D4D Coalition will present on its work at the g0v Summit in Taiwan from October 5 to 7, 2018, particularly the potential to develop disinformation monitoring efforts in Asia, with the support of partners, tools and techniques bolstered by D4D.

Sep 14, 2018

North Koreans Use Russian Tactics to Evade U.S. Sanctions

Capitalizing on weaknesses in U.S. technology and social media platforms, businesses in North Korea are able to connect with people in other countries to both provide and solicit services, circumventing U.S. sanctions. By hiding their identities, a group of North Korean web developers have allegedly advertised their services on Western online platforms and built a website for a business in Australia. A web of fake social media accounts and front companies in other countries enable this underground business.

Sep 14, 2018

In a Letter, Lawmakers Pressure the Intelligence Community to Confront Deepfakes

The prevalence of deepfakes, videos that are manipulated to show fake events, is increasing, prompting Rep. Adam B. Schiff (R-FL) and Stephanie Murphy (D-FL) to call for an analysis of the problem and solutions by the intelligence community. In their letter to the Director of National Intelligence, Daniel Coats, they call these videos a national security risk. Social media companies’ growing focus on stopping disinformation has been encouraged by pressure from Congress and the intelligence community and the lawmakers hope that the same trend will occur for the fight against deepfakes.

Sep 12, 2018

Ukraine Cybersecurity Training

On September 12, 2018, members of the Design 4 Democracy Coalition held an off-the-record workshop in Kyiv, Ukraine on emerging threats in disinformation and cybersecurity. Facilitated by NDI, IRI, IFES, and StopFake, the workshop included a range of organizations from civil society, government, technology companies and the cybersecurity community. Following lightning talks and presentations on research findings, participants took part in focused discussions on disinformation and cybersecurity in the lead up to the 2019 elections, as well as potential areas for improved collaboration with technology platforms to counter identified threats.

Sep 10, 2018

D4D Coalition Members Survey Upcoming Macedonian Referendum

The D4D team is actively engaged in Macedonia ahead of its historic national referendum on September 30, 2018. D4D is supporting efforts by local stakeholders to ensure that disinformation does not interfere with the ability of the Macedonian people to express their will.

Sep 6, 2018

Oxford’s Computational Propaganda Project Examines Swedish Election

The Oxford Internet Institute Computational Propaganda Project found that the upcoming Swedish election has experienced a high amount of ‘junk news’ shared by users on social media sites, second only to that seen in the 2016 U.S. presidential election. Some of these fake sites are modeled after reputable news sources, complicating users’ search for truth. Researchers were surprised to learn that eight of the ten most-shared fake news sites were domestic, causing a renewed focus on local actors over international influences.

Sep 6, 2018

Journalism, 'Fake News' and Disinformation: A Handbook for Journalism Education and Training

UNESCO published this handbook for use by journalism educators and publishing journalists. It includes discussions of journalism’s responsibilities regarding disinformation, misinformation, and mal-information. Written as a curriculum, this handbook covers everything from the current state of ‘fake news’, to the evolution of journalism, to recommendations moving forward.

Aug 29, 2018

Chinese Government Launches Rumor Refuting Platform

The Chinese government has created a national-level platform, run by the ‘Internet Illegal Information Reporting Center’ and run by Xinhua to publicly differentiate fact from fake news for its citizens. To create the platform, over 40 “rumor-refuting platforms” were combined into the official platform. The purpose behind the creation of this new official fact-checker, state-run explains, was to stop rumors and illegal information from disturbing the social order.

Aug 27, 2018

Facebook Lags in Efforts to Curb Anti-Muslim Hate Speech in Myanmar

A Reuters special report documents more than 1,000 posts, comments, and crude images on Facebook calling for violence and discrimination against Myanmar’s Muslims. Despite official rules banning such hate speech, Facebook appeared largely unprepared to crack down on this wave of anti-Muslim posts. For a long time, the organization lacked enough Burmese speaking employees, as well as programs that can effectively detect hate speech in the language and systems to translate the text, among other limitations preventing an effective response. It has also recently blocked the accounts of 18 users and 52 pages that are linked to Myanmar’s military, further highlighting the country’s worsening relationship with the world’s largest social media network.

Aug 24, 2018

Facebook’s Community Standards Have Huge Effects Worldwide

A recent piece from Vice Motherboard discusses the catch-22 that Facebook is confronting as it trying to create a standard moderating strategy for a world where local context is critically important to such moderation. Confronting mounting criticism from many quarters, the company has recently increased its focus and number of employees moderating false news and other posts that violate its Community Standards. Is it possible for Facebook to maintain a platform at global scale that is both safe and open?

Aug 21, 2018

Southeast Asia Messaging App ‘Line’ Struggles with Rising Health Misinformation

The messaging platform Line has seen a large increase in the quantity of content posted by users that spread incorrect information, especially about healthcare. These posts, which often target elderly users, advertise fake products or share incorrect information, like the power of kale juice to cure bone pain. Line is working with fact-checking organizations and the government to attempt to combat the problem.

Aug 21, 2018

Microsoft Discovers Websites Linked to Russian Intelligence Targeting Senate, IRI

A hacking group affiliated with the Russian government and linked to interference in the 2016 election, APT28, is believed to be behind the creation of six websites that mimic government and public policy groups. The U.S. Senate, International Republican Institute, and the Hudson Institute were among those targeted by the sites, which appear to seek credentials from members of these organizations. Microsoft, which discovered fake websites with domains like and, has announced plans to fight cybersecurity threats targeting political organizations. The tech company will offer free cybersecurity protections to likely targets of groups like APT28, including campaign offices and candidates, provided that they use Office 365 software.

Aug 21, 2018

Facebook Rates Users’ Credibility in an Attempt to Decrease False News

In response to incorrectly reported “false news” content, Facebook has begun to rate its users’ credibility based on thousands of behavioral points. Users who report content that is, in fact, false will have their future flags reviewed with higher priority than those who report many articles which are not false.

Aug 16, 2018

Politicians Are Placing Microtargeting on Facebook Under More Intense Scrutiny

Politicians in the US and Europe are devising new policies to limit microtargeting, a technique of targeting specific subgroups for advertisements which many believe is feeding polarization and voter manipulation. As researchers have identified, microtargeting has become a key weapon for foreign election meddlers, and many argue Facebook’s efforts to deter this exploitation of microtargeting has had little effect.

Aug 14, 2018

Workshops Reviewing Disinformation in Brazil, Colombia and Mexico Elections

NDI is planning a second disinformation event in collaboration with the Mexico National Electoral Institute (Instituto Nacional Electoral, INE) the Center for Research and Teaching in Economics (Centro de Investigacion y Docencias Economicas, CIDE) and the National Autonomous University of Mexico (Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico, UNAM). This will follow up on the forum held in March 2018 before the national elections in July, and will review the 2018 electoral process, highlight local efforts that tackled disinformation, and discuss lessons learned for future elections. Similar events are being held with NDI and FGV-DAPP participation in Brazil and Colombia throughout July and August.

Aug 14, 2018

Report Shows Major Foreign Influence on African Election Twitter Conversations

A Portland Communications survey of influencers shaping Twitter conversations on recent African elections shows that Africa is not immune to fake news, the rise of bots, or external influence on elections. The survey finds that 53% of key influencers came from outside the country holding the election, with many influencers coming from outside the continent. The report also reveals that bots had a major presence in election discourse while politicians had comparatively minor influence on discussions. Details on specific countries are provided.

Aug 14, 2018

Governments Are Using New Technologies to Attack and Silence Opponents

A report by the Institute for the Future reveals a widespread phenomenon of “state-sponsored trolling”: government use of targeted online hate and harassment campaigns to intimidate and silence individuals critical of the state. New surveillance and hacking technologies have allowed governments to anonymously track, threaten, and publicly delegitimize opponents on a greater scale than ever before. The report concludes with recommendations for technology companies, lawyers, and lawmakers.

Aug 14, 2018

Delegation Assesses Macedonian Disinformation Environment ahead of Referendum

A delegation including D4D partners visited Skopje, Macedonia in late July to assess potential for disinformation to impact the forthcoming referendum on a proposed change to country’s name and to better understand local needs for coordination and support. D4D partners continues to monitor the situation closely.

Aug 14, 2018

A History of Social Media from the Arab Spring to Today

This comprehensive essay details the myriad of political, social and business dynamics that transformed social media from the pro-democratic tool of the Arab Spring to the anti-democratic weapon of authoritarians and election-meddlers today. Writer Zeynep Tufekci points to the lack of regulations on tech firms, the unwillingness of the US to bolster its online defenses, and the appropriation of social media tools by authoritarians as key factors in this transition.

Aug 1, 2018

How Governments and Political Parties are Using Social Media to Shape Public Opinion

Oxford Internet Institute’s Project on Computational Propaganda has a new report analyzing the new and growing trends of organized media manipulation, as well as the growing capacities, strategies, and resources that support the trends. In a fast-growing number of countries, political parties and government agencies are using social media to manipulate domestic public opinion, often in response to threatening foreign interference and junk news. Since 2010, political parties and governments have spent over half a billion dollars developing and implementing these operations.

Aug 1, 2018

'Fake News' and Disinformation Throughout History: An Overview

This guide develops a learning module for journalists and educators meant to situate contemporary information disorder in a long history of misinformation, disinformation and propaganda. It establishes a broad historical overview of past forms of information disorder propagated by states, public figures, and the media. Established by the International Center for Journalists, the guide hopes to equip contemporary journalists and educators with a sharpened, contextual knowledge of disinformation-related issues.

Jul 30, 2018

Senate Report Offers 20 Policy Solutions to Big Tech, Information Disorder

The Office of Senate Intelligence Committee Vice Chairman Mark Warner prepared a policy paper detailing 20 ways that lawmakers can consider combating disinformation, protect user privacy, and promote competition in the tech space. These options include media literacy programs, new rules for social media platforms, and more user control over a company’s use of personal data.

Jul 29, 2018

UK Parliament Releases Report on Disinformation, Russian Interference and Data Targeting

The UK Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport, named Britain’s chief investigating authority on disinformation, released the first of its thorough reports on the subject. What began as an inquiry into a few major scandals turned into a comprehensive 89-page document on Russian interference, tech company responsibility for disinformation, Cambridge Analytica, and data targeting, putting the UK parliament at the center of global discussions. The report also includes a list of demands for regulation, legislation, codes of ethics and police investigations.

Jul 25, 2018

Facebook Deactivates Right-Wing Activist Pages in Brazil, Citing Misinformation

In its efforts to stop the spread of misinformation, Facebook deactivated a large network of pages and accounts thought to be led by Brazilian right-wing activists from the Movimento Brazil Livre (MBL), or “Free Brazil Movement.” According to a number of sources, MBL organizers posed as different independent news outlets to develop coordinated messaging campaigns in support of their policies. Facebook removed the accounts alleging that they violated the company’s authenticity policies.

Jul 25, 2018

European Union Tightens Grip on Google with Record-breaking Antitrust Fine

The European Union issued Google a record-breaking antitrust fine of €4.34 billion ($5.06 billion) over Google’s deals with mobile phone makers and telecommunications operators. According to EU regulators, Google’s contracts with phone makers effectively force those companies to prioritize Google apps and services in exchange for Google providing its Android operating system for free. The fine represents a major step towards stronger government oversight of technology companies, at least in the EU.

Jul 25, 2018

D4D Partner Getulio Vargas Foundation Launches Brazilian Digital Election Observatory

The Getulio Vargas Foundation Office of Public Policy (Fundação Getúlio Vargas, Diretoria de Análise de Politicas Publicas or FGV-DAPP) launched their Sala de Democracia Digital (Digital Democracy Room) at an event on July 25 in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil with support from NDI, including the participation of NDI’s Colombia Country Director Francisco Herrero. The online project seeks to analyze political discourse on the web during the 2018 Brazilian elections and will include weekly reports on the use of bots and fake news during the months prior to the October poll as well as policy papers and recommendations.

Jul 24, 2018

U.S. Loses Influence in Shaping of Global Internet Policy

As the EU and China push forward with tighter internet regulations, the US is losing its place as a key agenda-setter on internet freedom and cybersecurity policy. The US has lately been taking a far more passive role on countering authoritarian internet policies in China and other developing countries, and has neglected to confront the EU over its strict user privacy regulations that could threaten global cybersecurity efforts.

Jul 19, 2018

Uganda Keeps Controversial Social Media Tax despite Calls for Freedom of Expression

The parliament of Uganda temporarily maintained a controversial tax on social media use despite widespread protests against it. President Museveni, who first introduced the law, has cited the spread of “gossip” as a key reason for its existence. Seen as an attempt at state censorship, the tax has led to a significant drop in social media use in addition to creating new economic burdens for the Ugandan people.

Jul 18, 2018

Study Warns of Growing Presence of Bots on Instagram

A recent study by the research firm Ghost Data reveals that Instagram may have as many as 95 million bots, up slightly higher from 2015. Bot presence on Instagram continues to increase despite efforts by Facebook to curb the spread. The rise in Instagram bots is especially concerning since images and videos, uniquely difficult to track and identify, could play a larger role in coming elections.

Jul 18, 2018

Investigation Uncovers New Players Behind Macedonian Fake News Scandal

A joint investigation by the Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (OCCRP) and partners reveals that Macedonia’s fake American news industry in Veles was launched by well-known Macedonian attorney Trajche Arsov, not by apolitical teens as previously reported. During the 2016 election, Arsov worked closely with several high-profile American partners to churn out over a hundred fake news websites on social media. Macedonian security agencies are now cooperating with law enforcement in the US and several other European countries to investigate possible ties between Arsov and the recently indicted Russian hackers.

Jul 18, 2018

Facebook to Strengthen Moderation of False Information in Response to Violence

In light of episodes of ethnic violence in Myanmar, India and Sri Lanka, Facebook has announced tighter restrictions on disinformation and misinformation spread through its site and Instagram. The company will start effectively removing false information that might lead to physical harm. However, the policy does not apply to WhatsApp, which has been a major catalyst for recent violent incidents.

Jul 16, 2018

Pioneering Bill Requiring Bots to Self-disclose Moves through California State Legislature

A bill that would require certain automated social media accounts to identify themselves as bots is currently moving through the California state legislature. Many critics charge that the proposed law lacks specifics, that it is not constitutional, or that it will not effectively solve the problem of bot influence on voters. The bill, among the first of its kind, demonstrates the challenges that face lawmakers seeking legislative solutions to the surge of automated accounts.

Jul 16, 2018

Inviting Collaboration from Civic Tech Stakeholders at Tbilisi’s OGP Summit

On July 16, NDI and Coalition partners convened a forum at the margins of the OGP Summit in Tbilisi, Georgia, titled “Scaling the Future of Civic Tech.” The day-long event featured discussions on ways the civic tech movement is strengthening democracy in particular national and subnational contexts and highlighted the D4D Coalition as a means of sustaining collaboration on shared priorities.

Jul 12, 2018

Russian Disinformation Campaign Exploited Americans’ Stronger Trust in Local News

New findings reveal that Russian propagators of disinformation often posed as local news sources to exploit the American public’s higher levels of trust for local news organizations. Many fake local news Twitter accounts did not actually post false information, opting instead to establish long-term credibility for when they needed to operationalize. These cases further confirm that the Russian-led disinformation campaign has been years in the making.

Jul 11, 2018

Twitter Escalates Action against Bots, Removing Millions of Suspicious Accounts

Twitter has escalated its defense against fake accounts and bots in the past few months, suspending more than one million accounts a day. This is especially significant given the company’s usual prioritization of freedom of speech over policing users’ behavior. In an effort to promote trust amongst active users, Twitter has already removed large amounts of inactive or suspicious follower accounts thought to be promoting disinformation and spam.

Jul 9, 2018

YouTube Reveals Plan to Promote More Trustworthy News Sources on its Site

YouTube has announced a series of developments meant to promote more reliable, “authoritative” news sources on its site. The proposed changes mark a departure from the platform’s current video recommendation algorithms, which have promoted factually incorrect conspiracy theory videos to users who had a history of watching similar ones.

Jul 9, 2018

WhatsApp Responds to Harmful Fake News Campaigns Spread through the App

Frightened mobs in India have killed two dozen innocent people as false rumors about child kidnapping spread through the widely-used messaging platform WhatsApp. The app has facilitated the proliferation of false information in countries across the world, leading to instances of physical harm in Brazil and Sri Lanka as well. Not only does WhatsApp host the majority of viral disinformation campaigns in the most amount of countries, but its encryption and private messaging systems also make it uniquely difficult to slow these campaigns. In response to these trends, WhatsApp has placed restrictions on the amount of contacts that users can forward messages to. WhatsApp also announced plans to support third-party developers of fact-checking technology for the app.

Jul 9, 2018

D4D Advisory Board Member Testifies to US Senate on Foreign Influence Operations

Philip Howard, Director of the Oxford Internet Institute (OII) and D4D advisory board member, testified before the Senate Intelligence Committee on the work of OII’s computational propaganda project, state sponsored disinformation worldwide, and the potential for foreign influence operations targeting U.S. elections.

Jul 9, 2018

Creating a Shared Vocabulary around Information Disorder

First Draft, a project of Harvard University’s John F. Kennedy School of Government, published a definitional toolbox of terms related to technology and misinformation. The toolbox aims to create a shared vocabulary amongst policymakers, citizens, and academics. Part One includes a glossary defining “commonly used” and “frequently misunderstood” terms related to information disorder. Part Two attempts to map the thirteen sub-categories of the information disorder field in order to facilitate more strategic, targeted research and action. Part Three includes downloadable high-resolution graphics created to help explain information disorder.

Jul 7, 2018

Brazilian Network of Facebook Page and Like Sales Revealed

An investigation by the Digital Forensic Research Lab reveals a deep network of exchanges between various users and several Brazil-based groups that sell pages, likes, and shares on Facebook for money. Like and share for cash transactions at large scale have the potential to threaten the integrity of Brazil’s upcoming elections, also a concern in Mexico’s recent elections that were also flooded with messages from inauthentic accounts.

Jul 3, 2018

WhatsApp’s Growing Role in Political Messaging across the Global South

Research conducted by the German Tactical Technology Collective and their partners reveals that WhatsApp is now the primary platform for political messaging across the Global South, especially in rural areas with limited internet access. The report analyzes this phenomenon, seeking to answer why WhatsApp is such a powerful tool, how politicians and campaigners use the platform, what strategies organizers use to exploit the platform and what the potential implications are of this trend. The report also includes several case studies of key countries impacted by WhatsApp.

Jul 2, 2018

Controversial Law in Vietnam Gives Government Broad Access Users’ Personal Data

Vietnam recently approved a new controversial cybersecurity law regulating technology firms’ use of personal data. The legislation requires that social media firms turn over subscriber information, IP addresses, and account information to the Ministry of Public Security and remove content from their platforms when requested by the government. The legislation also creates formulations for charging citizens for posting “anti-government propaganda” or any material that “incites violence and disturbs public security.”

Jun 23, 2018

Former Secretary of State Madeleine K. Albright References the D4D Coalition in Berlin

From June 22-23, 2018, the Atlantic Council’s Digital Forensics Lab hosted the 360/OS open source summit in Berlin, bringing together journalists, activists, innovators, and leaders from around the world as part of our digital solidarity movement for objective facts and reality — a cornerstone of democracy.

Jun 22, 2018

Coalition Representatives Support the Copenhagen Democracy Summit

Representatives from the Design for Democracy Coalition attended the Copenhagen Democracy Summit, organized and hosted by the Alliance of Democracies, with the sponsorship of a wide array of organizations including Microsoft, Facebook, the University of Denver, NDI and IRI.

Jun 18, 2018

Coalition Partners Contribute to Discussion on Tech's Role in the Rise of Populism

Several D4D Coalition partners convened in Brussels to participate in the forum “Representation in the Age of Populism: Ideas for Global Action,” organized by the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (International IDEA).

Jun 8, 2018

Strengthening the Inter-Parliamentary Component of Regional and Security Cooperation

On June 8-9, the Verkhovna Rada, Ukraine’s unicameral parliamentary body, hosted a conference to discuss current threats on democracy, which came as a follow-up to the Chairman of the Verkhovna Rada’s official visit to Moldova in March of this year.

Jun 22, 2018

Coalition Partners Launch European Cybersecurity Playbook

Supporting partners of the Design 4 Democracy Coalition, the National Democratic Institute (NDI) and the International Republican Institute (IRI), along with the Defending Digital Democracy project (D3P) at Harvard Kennedy School’s Belfer Center, convened at Google’s Belgium office for the public launch of the “The Cybersecurity Campaign Playbook: European Edition” on May 22, 2018. The event featured a series of discussions including D3P Senior Fellows Robby Mook and Matt Rhoades, representatives from Microsoft and Google, European parliamentarians and policymakers, and officials from the Belfer Center, IRI and NDI.

Apr 19, 2018

Popular Chinese-American Platform, WeChat, Proves Susceptible to Misinformation

WeChat, a social media platform popular with Chinese Immigrants in the United States, presents new challenges and a new perspective to the fight against misinformation. The platform heavily features local news and sensational stories, while passing over other popular topics including the economy and healthcare. WeChat shows many of the same characteristics as misinformation in mainstream media, but also displays ways in which immigrant populations diverge from norms because of its blend of U.S. media and Chinese media practices. On the platform, conservative voices feature loudly, with both liberal and conservative users discussing the role of Chinese immigrants in politics and in the United States.